The Photo Album isn't what put
Death Cab for Cutie on the proverbial indie map, however it
did put their poster on Seth Cohen's wall. Yes, 2003's
Transatlanticism was their breakout LP, however its quieter 2001 predecessor remains steadfastly beloved for its melodic highs (and boasting potentially the band's
best song). On record, penultimate track "Coney Island" is rainy and understated; on the recently unearthed musical group demo" version — set to appear on a forthcoming 20th anniversary deluxe reissue — the song imagines a parallel universe where Death Cab pivoted to alt-country at the turn of the new millennium. Alternatively opposed to Chris Walla's stuttering drum sample, this version rests on twangy guitar the likes of which I personally would've expected from
Ben Gibbard's Neil Young sideburns era several years later. Without consideration, it sounds welcome and warm, if a touch out of character. That's what makes it so novel. —
Patrick Hosken